Conservatives do not inherently hold anti-immigration stances, in 1986 Ronald Reagan signed an immigration bill that granted amnesty for the nation’s then three million undocumented immigrants. The Democrats have not always been pro immigration we need look no further than Bill Clinton’s 1995 State of the Union Address or Obama who was called by some the “Deporter in Chief”.
Yet, from a certain cynical electoral logic, both of the viable American political parties should be in favor of not only of immigration but also mass amnesty. There has been a discussion around liberals trying to steal election via open borders policies. Figures like Tony from 1Dime Radio have spoken to this along with Elon Musk who tweeted, “Since illegals are mostly in Democrat states, both the House and the Presidential vote are shifted ~5% to the left, which is enough to change the entire balance of power.”
But immigrants are not guaranteed to vote in one direction or another, let alone their children, no deal is struck but perhaps a likeliness for immigrants to vote for the party that was kind to them and their parents. Yet, this does not always follow through. As a Cuban-American and Miami resident my communities are filled with immigrants with a conservative mindset plus a GOP voting pattern. This is despite the fact that many of Miami’s immigrants came in during Democrats John F. Kennedy, Lyndon B. Johnson, and Joe Biden.
But if voters do indeed favor parties that assist them then any party who would grant mass amnesty to undocumented immigrants is likely to earn themselves a heap of voters, be they Republican or Democrat. While mass amnesty in the vain of Ronald Reagan would not be popular to run on, passing a round of amnesty while in power would be a viable electoral strategy under logics where immigration is a tool to swing elections.
Yet, clearly immigration shifts do not alter who wins elections in any short term sense. Despite there having been a high amount of Irish and Italian immigration from the 1870s to the 1920s, there was not a Catholic president until 1961 with John F. Kennedy. It is also important to note that citizen who happen to be immigrants do not always vote and undocumented immigrants can’t vote.
However, if the Republican Party and others really think that undocumented immigration is a tool to win elections, why would the Republicans not use this tool themselves? Or better asked, if undocumented immigration can be a tool to win elections why would it be a one-sided tool in favor of Democrats? If you are in favor of mass amnesty, like myself, then a strategy where Republicans are convinced to seek mass amnesty on an electoral basis could help achieve those ends.
I personally take immigration to be a non-issue, in the sense that I think freedom of movement ought to be upheld except for those who commit violent crimes. Were the three million people Reagan granted amnesty to violent criminal terrorists, did they destroy the culture, did they take all the welfare benefits, of course not. If Republicans care about freedom, then freedom of movement should be added to that list. And by granting mass amnesty perhaps you would earn some life long Republicans via upholding the principle of the freedom of movement. So here their is a value and electoral basis for granting mass amnesty.
The stances of the GOP and DNC as they exist do not have be the permanent case. If America is truly a nation of immigrants and our systems were built around immigration, then ensuring immigrants can participate in America’s processes will keep American systems turning. But these sorts of platitudes have not been effective, even if accurate, so instead there is an opportunity to take advantage of conservative rhetoric which equates open border policies to vote rigging.
What is needed is not to change conservative logic, there is no inherent conservative logic, instead appeals toward mass amnesty can be won amongst conservatives using specific conservative logics. There is not one way to be a conservative or liberal, or one way to be conservative or liberal on immigration, and those who are against mass deportation ought to find every tool to sway the public against draconian immigration policies, this would include having Republicans see that mass amnesty would be beneficial politically.

